Restaurant Review: Degustation
August 31st, 2009 by plumpdumpling

My boyfriend got a sudden urge for a tasting menu last week, so I posted to Chowhound seeking a menu without much seafood to suit me. Someone suggested Degustation, where we’ve been meaning to go anyway, and even though the restaurant has no website of its own to post a menu on, other people’s reviews seemed to suggest the place was right up my alley.

It’s basically located in an alley, so we almost missed it, and then when the friendly hostess came to greet us, it turned out we weren’t on their reservation list. I chalked it up to the unpleasant telephone exchange I’d had with the reservationist the day before in which I supposedly mispronounced the name of the place, but then the hostess asked, “Is the reservation for day-gus-TAY-shun or our sister restaurant, Jewel Bako?” After I finished mentally rejoicing that someone who actually works there pronounces it the same way I did, another employee came over and led us to our seats, even though it was clear we didn’t have a reservation. So A+ to the restaurant staff for clearing up the issue, and F- to reservationist for mucking up my self-esteem and my good name (kidding).

We loved the set-up of Degustation. The 16-seat wooden bar makes a half-rectangle around the kitchen so that you can see your food being prepared and the chef can watch you enjoying it. The diners were a mix of young couples like ourselves who were all ordering the 10-course tasting menu and older couples who had obviously been there before and were enjoying glass after glass of wine. The couple next to me seemed to order every single dish on the menu, and I only noticed because the old man kept punching me in the side with his elbow and cutting his meat with his arm all up in my business, and I was dying for them to leave. Of course I assumed he was mistreating me because he knew I was too poor to be eating there, but I tried to keep my paranoia in check.

Chef Wesley Genovart is there in the middle.

Our amuse-bouche was a croquet of corn and pork and a tortilla folded around a nearly-raw quail egg over shallot jam. The croquet was a little too mushy inside, but the shell was perfectly crisp, and corn can do no wrong in my book. I made the mistake of not eating the tortilla in one bite, so the egg leaked out all over my plate, but it gave me a better chance to mix it into the very complimentary shallot jam.

Our first course was a chilled almond soup with champagne grapes and raw almonds. The combination of grapes and almonds was even better than I expected, and as someone who doesn’t care for the texture of almonds, I loved being able to experience the flavor without finding nut bits in my teeth for hours afterward.

Our second course was broccoli rabe two ways with parmesan broth and pineapple foam. The fried rabe was probably the best preparation I’ve ever tasted, but it kept getting soft in the parmesan broth before I could get it into my mouth. The pineapple foam was delicious and inventive, but Kamran didn’t think it mixed well with the broth.

The third course was a heirloom tomato summer salad with basil, egg vinaigrette, and a hunk of pork. Tomatoes are the one food I absolutely can’t bear to eat, so I was extremely disappointed to see an entire course centered on them. When the server asked if I was allergic to anything, I should have just told her I can’t eat tomatoes and bypassed the whole thing, but I thought I could tough out anything they brought me. Kamran told me that his tasted sweet, so I tried a bite of each of the five kinds on my plate, but it took everything I had not to make disgusted faces. He tasted some of mine and agreed that they weren’t as good as his. Luckily, I love basil, and the pork was done really, really well, with an extra-crispy skin.

The fourth course was smoked sea trout with red onions and scallion cream cheese. I don’t generally like fish, but I can eat raw salmon, and this reminded me a lot of that. I didn’t notice the smoky flavor until Kamran pointed it out to me, but the onions were a great addition, as were these tiny green cubes of something incredibly spicy. We couldn’t name them, but we loved them.

The couple around the corner of the bar from us were one course ahead of us, so I knew ahead of time that sardines were coming. When it comes to fish–and especially the very last kind of fish I’d ever eat if given a choice–having more time to prepare myself for it isn’t the way to go. Knowing what was coming, I kept asking questions about it to Kamran, who could do nothing to assuage my extreme horror at the idea of having to eat fish skin. Let me just show you the picture so you’ll have an idea of how gross this plate looked.

I was even more horrified when ol’ Jabby Elbow next to me asked if he and his wife could have the sardines off the menu. “We just love sardines!” the woman said. The server told them the dish was only part of the 10-course tasting menu, so as much as I wanted to slide my plate over to them, I reveled in the fact that I had something they couldn’t have.

The first preparation was pickled with a sort of tartar sauce underneath. The taste of it didn’t bother me all that much, honestly, but I just couldn’t get past the slippery skin. Seeing the shiny silver was bad enough, but feeling it slide across my tongue was just awful. I had to give it to Kamran, who told me he’d buy me ice cream later just for trying it.

The second was fried with pickled onions, and it was the best of the three for me, simply because it didn’t look like fish.

But to be honest, the grilled piece actually tasted the best. I love the taste of blackened anything, so it really helped me enjoy the fish. As much as I could ever hope to enjoy a sardine, I mean. (My friend the bachelor girl tells me that she actually likes sardines, though, so it’s not just old people.)

I was very much bored of fish at this point, and the next dish only made it worse. It was a skin-on dorade with matsutake mushrooms and dashi broth. The fish seemed to be cooked well and all, but the dish was just plain boring. It looked bland, and it tasted bland.

I was really looking forward to the seventh course simply because I’ve always wanted to eat something out of a hollow egg. We’d seen a carton of eggshells with their tops cut off sitting on a high shelf above the chef and were excited about the possibility of being served something in them, and what we got was more interesting than I had expected.

It was a duck egg custard with maple syrup, brioche, and bacon. The custard was a little thin, but the sweetness of the maple syrup with it was really nice, as was the crunchiness of the brioche. The dish itself was just good, but the presentation of the egg in a bowl of salt was great.

The eighth course was the first one that really left me impressed. It was chicken confit on toasted bread with a smear of curry and a salad of watercress, celery, and huckleberries. Neither of us had ever had huckleberries, so that was exciting in itself, but the chicken confit was exactly what I’d needed all night. It was comfort food, but the curry and the confit preparation added an exciting twist.

I was just watching something the other day where a chef complained about how sweetbreads are always fried and how he’d like to see them grilled just once, but it turns out there’s a reason they’re always fried. Grilled sweetbreads are like a glob of gelatin with a bit of organ flavor.

If that doesn’t convince you, let me give you a nice close-up.

Now, I had sweetbreads at wd~50 and was blown away by how surprisingly pleasant they were, but this would’ve been a much better dish had it just been the summer corn, the tomatillo salsa, and the delfino, a wonderful herb that we’d never even heard of. But it wasn’t.

Thank god the dessert was amazing. I was extremely disappointed when I heard the server tell another patron that their dessert menu consisted of exactly one item, a caramelized torija. I didn’t know what a torija was, but I knew it wouldn’t interest me. It turns out, though, that you only need one dessert when it’s this good.

It was a hunk of bread, torched until golden on the outside and left doughy on the inside, served with three kinds of berries. It was DELICIOUS. And I’m not the sort of person who thinks chocolateless, ice-creamless desserts are delicious. It was definitely the highlight of the meal, Kamran and I both agreed. One of the servers asked us how we liked it, and when we made gurgling sounds of appreciation, she told us that a couple in the night before had ordered one round of the dessert, then another, then another. And when he requested thirds, the man said, “Make mine a double.” That’s how good it is.

We consider Degustation an experience that we’re glad we had, but it just doesn’t compare to our dinner at craft or wd~50. We think part of the problem might have been that everyone hyped it so much to us that our expectations were too high. We also think that the overabundance of seafood was a problem, and I’m sure that had I asked, they would’ve prepared something else for me. (Or just given me four of those wonderful desserts.)

The tasting menu is a value, though, undoubtedly. For $75 each, we got 10 courses of good food with a couple of great moments in a unique atmosphere. I wouldn’t necessarily go back myself, but I’d certainly recommend it to others as a one-time experience. Plus, it gave me the chance to write my first half-negative review, which is pretty exciting.

15 Responses  
  • Tracey writes:
    August 31st, 20098:23 pmat

    What? All pictures of food and none of the faces you made at it?

    Now it’s time to come to Ohio and eat nothing but Dairy Queen for a week! Yay!

    • plumpdumpling writes:
      September 1st, 200910:34 amat

      Dairy Queen is exactly what I needed after that meal. Kamran’s a painfully slow eater who’s always finishing well after me at home, but he finished every single one of these plates well ahead of me. I eventually realized it’s because we always order things I’m really comfortable with at home, whereas these dishes were very scary to me.

      I really tried to control my faces, but I kept making comments like, “Let’s get out of here before the sardines come,” and I worried that the chef might have overheard me and gotten offended. Although then maybe he’d put better stuff on the menu.

  • TLB writes:
    August 31st, 20099:54 pmat

    Beautiful pics, Donut! But I’d take a Quarter Pounder (or donuts) over sweetbreads any ol’ day. :)

    • plumpdumpling writes:
      September 1st, 200912:04 pmat

      Meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee, too! But I’m happy to eat sweetbreads every now and then just so my opinion of them is justified. Unlike my opinion of, say, tripe, which is entirely based on suppositions of it being nasty.

      These are my favourite food photos I’ve taken so far. If only every restaurant had such decent lighting.

  • Bill writes:
    September 1st, 200911:03 amat

    I really don’t understand how someone can seem to care about food and write a food blog yet get so easily disgusted by normal things. Summer tomatoes when perfectly ripe are one of the best things on this planet. I get that people did not like them as children, but you are an adult now and you really should try and get over it. I am not saying this to chide you but rather that you should enjoy one of natures best delicacies. A perfect marriage of sweet, sour, umami and bitter.

    As for the fish, it all left my mouth watering, especially the sardines(not just for old people). Once again, one of nature’s perfect food. Fish skin, like any animal’s skin is one of the best parts filled with unctuous fatty goodness. There are reasons people go nuts for it so I encourage you to keep trying it, for you are missing out on another great delicacy.

    • plumpdumpling writes:
      September 1st, 200912:18 pmat

      Man, you’re tellin’ me. My life would be 100 times better if I just liked tomatoes! My boyfriend used to hate them as a kid but doesn’t have much of a problem with them anymore, and he’s constantly teasing me for still being a child. I try to eat them as much as I can, hoping that it’s just in my mind, but I genuinely don’t like the taste still. Woe is me.

      The fish thing I’m slowly getting over. I grew up on a pig/cattle/sheep farm, so I was just never fed any seafood. I recognize that I don’t dislike the taste of most of it–and actually enjoy some of it–so I know it’s a mental thing. It’s kind of interesting having had very few diverse foods as a kid, though, because it means lots of foods are still exciting and new to me as an adult.

  • Kelly writes:
    September 1st, 20093:20 pmat

    The one thing I DON’T like about sardines is how the taste of them stays with you for at least 24 hours afterward. Did that happen to you?

    My other question: do people in restaurants ever give you shit about taking pictures of your food? I’m just curious because I do it a lot, especially in fine-dining restaurants, and the reactions of the staff and other diners range wildly from “totally normal yet flattering thing to do” to “OMG WTF YOU’RE TAKING PICTURES OF FOOD?! WTF OH NOES!!1!”

    • plumpdumpling writes:
      September 2nd, 20093:12 pmat

      I plan to be tasting these things for six weeks. At least.

      No one’s ever said a thing about it to me. I’m guessing food blogging is so popular these days that the best restaurants are used to it, though I’d give myself funny looks, too, if I was taking photos at McDonald’s. The setting at Degustation was so intimate that I asked the server if it was okay, and she said sure, as long as I didn’t use a flash.

      I was like, “FLASH?! Are you serious?” But I’m sure they get that sometimes. The funny thing is that asking if it was okay made me feel much more comfortable doing it. Usually, I feel like I have to sneak my camera out of my bag under the table and take pictures when everyone’s backs are turned, but after admitting that I was going to do it, I felt free to take multiple shots of everything. Lesson learned.

      What do you usually do?

  • nat @book, line, and sinker writes:
    September 24th, 200911:37 pmat

    i am reeling from this…it’s like shock and awe for me. why, oh why does sweetbread have such a deceiving name?!?!?!?!? i thought it was some delish dessert or something. and fish with SKIN?!? sardines???

    you are the ponce de leon of food, my dear. you win, hands down. i would have packed my bags at the mere suggestion of a quail egg.

    i’ll be waiting for you at the dairy queen.

    • plumpdumpling writes:
      October 1st, 200910:52 amat

      Hey, DQ is still the best in my book. It’s kinda funny that Kamran has me eating all of this stuff here, and then I go home to Ohio to visit and eat nothing but Applebee’s.

      But yes, sweetbreads are a cruel, cruel joke.

  • The Duo Dishes writes:
    September 30th, 20098:08 pmat

    You eat so well! Never had sweetbreads, but those look GOOD. Hmmm, may have to try them…

    • plumpdumpling writes:
      October 1st, 200910:56 amat

      Do not let the sweetbreads fool you! They look like cute little balls of chicken kebab or something, but they are vile and intend to kill your tastebuds!

      Except when they’re breaded and fried. Then they’re awesome.

  • I Would Do Anything for a Free Dinner (Including That) — Unapologetically Mundane writes:
    May 17th, 201112:04 pmat

    […] he started saying, “I really feel like going to Degustation for a tasting menu. I wish you’d make an appointment so we could go.” So I said, […]

  •» Blog Archive » Degustation Chef’s Ten-Course Tasting Menu – Spanish/Tapas – East Village writes:
    May 24th, 201111:34 amat

    […] complaint now, I still don’t find it the least bit comforting or homey. And it was actually my first time at Degustation that I tried fish skin for the first time. At least that was attached to a piece of actual fish, […]

  • The Canon S90 Has Been Released, and I Can Finally Move on with My Life — Unapologetically Mundane writes:
    May 26th, 201110:54 amat

    […] every waiting list in town and was content to sit quietly for a while, but when the photos for my Degustation review turned out so much better than all of my other food photos just because of a little light […]

»  Admin   »  Substance:WordPress   »  Style:Ahren Ahimsa and Katie Ett